Beyond ZTNA
A Technical Comparison of Five Access Architectures. By Michael Oldham, Founder, PortSys.
The evidence behind The Enforcement Gap
Every access vendor can verify an identity. What separates architectures is what happens after the login: where enforcement sits, what triggers reevaluation, which applications are covered, how device trust is established, whose infrastructure the traffic crosses, and what the whole thing costs to operate.
Beyond ZTNA applies those six criteria, identically, to the five categories of access architecture on the market — including the category PortSys competes in: identity-centric platforms, cloud-delivered security service edge (SSE) platforms, application delivery controllers, traditional VPN appliances, and self-hosted unified enforcement proxies.
What’s inside
- An evaluation framework. Six criteria for comparing access architectures — enforcement location, reevaluation triggers, application coverage, device trust model, deployment and data path, and operational model — applied identically to every category.
- The architectural landscape. Each of the five categories examined in depth: how it works, how it handles continuous evaluation, its strengths, its limits against the criteria, and where it fits best — with a full summary comparison table.
- Device management versus access-time inspection. Why they are different capabilities, and why the distinction matters most for the devices your organization does not own.
- The operational cost of depth. The staffing plan hidden inside multi-product platforms — and why an architecture that cannot be fully staffed is not the architecture that was evaluated.
- Where each approach fits best. An honest matching of architectures to situations — including the ones where ours is not the answer.
- Questions to ask any vendor. The question set we would bring to any access evaluation — and we encourage you to ask every one of them of PortSys too.
Who it’s for
Security architects, identity and access teams, and anyone running a Zero Trust evaluation who needs the detail behind the claims. If you want the business argument first, start with the companion paper, The Enforcement Gap — it makes the case in ten pages; this paper carries the evidence.
Keep Reading
Why breaches keep happening after the login — and what to do about it. The business case this analysis supports.
Read the PaperNine evaluation criteria and a ten-question checklist — including the questions to ask us.
Read the PaperReady to See TAC in Action?
Book a 30-minute session with a PortSys engineer and see how TAC addresses your specific environment and compliance requirements.
Request a Demo